Trucking Jobs: Idaho vs Montana
Side-by-side comparison of salaries, cost of living, taxes, job availability, freight routes, and CDL requirements for truck drivers.
Higher Pay
Tied
Lower COL
Montana
More Jobs
Idaho
Lower Tax
Comparable
Salary Comparison
Tie| Metric | Idaho | Montana |
|---|---|---|
| Average Salary | $60,000 | $60,000 |
| Salary Range | $48,000 - $72,000 | $47,000 - $72,000 |
| Minimum | $48,000 | $47,000 |
| Maximum | $72,000 | $72,000 |
Cost of Living & Taxes
Montana wins| Metric | Idaho | Montana |
|---|---|---|
| COL Index (100 = national avg) | 98 | 96 |
| State Income Tax | 5.695% flat | 4.7% flat |
Job Availability
Idaho wins| Metric | Idaho | Montana |
|---|---|---|
| Job Availability Rating | Moderate | Moderate |
| Est. Annual CDL Openings | 2,800 | 2,200 |
Top Trucking Companies
Idaho
- 1J.R. Simplot (private fleet)
- 2Lamb Weston
- 3Idaho Timber
- 4Boise Cascade
- 5Western States Equipment
Montana
- 1Watkins & Shepard
- 2Bretz RV & Marine
- 3Town Pump
- 4Cenex (private fleet)
- 5Knife River
Key Freight Routes
Idaho
- I-84 (Boise–Twin Falls–OR/UT)
- I-15 (Pocatello–Montana)
- I-86 (American Falls–Pocatello)
- US-95 (north–south)
Montana
- I-90 (Billings–Missoula)
- I-15 (Great Falls–Helena–Butte)
- I-94 (Billings–Miles City–ND)
- US-2 (northern Hi-Line)
CDL Requirements
Idaho
Min Age: 18 (intrastate), 21 (interstate)
18 for intrastate, 21 for interstate. Idaho Transportation Department administers CDL testing.
Montana
Min Age: 18 (intrastate), 21 (interstate)
18 for intrastate, 21 for interstate. Montana MVD administers CDL testing.
Weather & Driving Conditions
Idaho
Weather
Cold snowy winters in mountains. Hot dry summers in Boise valley. Mountain pass conditions.
Driving Challenges
Mountain passes on I-84, winter chain requirements, rural stretches on US-95, wildlife hazards.
Montana
Weather
Harsh winters with extreme cold and heavy snow. Mountain conditions. Chinook winds can change temps rapidly.
Driving Challenges
Mountain passes on I-90, extreme cold, long distances between services, wildlife (deer/elk/moose) on highways.
Overall Comparison Summary
Higher Pay
Tie
Lower COL
MT
More Jobs
ID
Lower Tax
Tie
Both states are evenly matched across our comparison categories. Your decision should come down to personal preferences—weather, proximity to family, and the type of freight you want to haul.
Frequently Asked Questions: Idaho vs Montana
How does trucking compare in Idaho and Montana?
Idaho has slightly more openings (2,800 vs 2,200) and comparable pay ($48K–$72K range). Idaho's 5.695% flat tax is higher than Montana's 4.7% flat. Both states have low costs of living and limited but steady trucking markets. Idaho benefits from Boise's rapid growth; Montana benefits from energy sector hauling.
What freight types are available in Idaho vs Montana?
Idaho: agricultural (potatoes, dairy, grain), lumber/timber, food processing (J.R. Simplot, Lamb Weston), and growing tech sector logistics (Micron/HP). Montana: energy (Bakken-adjacent), ranching/agriculture, timber, and tourism supplies. Both states handle significant I-90/I-15 through-traffic.
What are the driving challenges unique to the northern Rockies?
Both states have mountain passes, wildlife hazards (moose, elk, deer), extreme winter cold, and long distances between services. Idaho's I-84 through the Snake River Canyon and Montana's I-90 through the Bitterroot Mountains are both technically demanding. Drivers in both states need winter experience and self-sufficiency skills.
Explore Each State
Ready to Drive in Idaho?
Submit your profile and get matched with carriers hiring CDL drivers in your preferred state.