ABF Freight (ArcBest) vs Old Dominion Freight Line
ABF is a Teamsters union LTL carrier under ArcBest. Old Dominion is non-union with profit sharing. ABF offers union protections and pension; Old Dominion offers higher total compensation.
ABF Freight (ArcBest)
- Pay
- $60,000 - $95,000
- Fleet
- 4,000+ tractors
- Rating
- 3.9/5
Old Dominion Freight Line
- Pay
- $65,000 - $100,000+
- Fleet
- 10,000+ tractors
- Rating
- 4.5/5
Head-to-Head Comparison
Pay
ABF Freight (ArcBest)
ABF pays $60K-$95K under Teamsters contract with union-scale wages.
Old Dominion Freight Line
Old Dominion pays $65K-$100K+ with substantial profit sharing.
Home Time
ABF Freight (ArcBest)
City drivers home daily; road bids determined by union seniority.
Old Dominion Freight Line
City drivers home daily; linehaul on predictable weekly schedules.
Benefits
ABF Freight (ArcBest)
ABF offers Teamsters health and welfare, pension, paid holidays, seniority protections.
Old Dominion Freight Line
Old Dominion provides profit sharing, 401(k), stock purchase, and health coverage.
Training/Support
ABF Freight (ArcBest)
ABF requires 1 year; union seniority governs route and shift selection.
Old Dominion Freight Line
Old Dominion requires 1 year; merit-based advancement culture.
Equipment/Technology
ABF Freight (ArcBest)
ABF's fleet is adequate; ArcBest has been investing in modernization.
Old Dominion Freight Line
Old Dominion operates modern equipment across 250+ service centers.
Our Verdict
Old Dominion is the better total compensation package with profit sharing and stock purchase. ABF is the choice for drivers who value union representation and pension. If union membership matters, ABF delivers. If maximizing income matters, Old Dominion wins.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is union at ABF worth it vs non-union ODFL?
Depends on priorities. ABF gives seniority, pension, collective bargaining. ODFL gives higher total pay through profit sharing.
Which has better retirement?
ABF has Teamsters pension. ODFL has profit sharing + 401(k) + stock. ODFL likely comes out ahead total, but pension is guaranteed.
Which is harder to get into?
Old Dominion. Their low turnover means fewer openings.