Skip to content

Compare Trucking Companies Side-by-Side

Not sure which carrier is right for you? Our detailed comparisons break down pay, benefits, home time, equipment quality, and career growth opportunities to help you make an informed decision.

Popular Comparisons

Werner Enterprises

3.8/5 rating

VS

Schneider National

4/5 rating

Score: 34Score: 38

Werner and Schneider are two of the most established mega carriers in America, both offering CDL training programs for new drivers. Werner leans into dedicated and OTR dry van freight, while Schneider provides more diverse divisions including tanker and intermodal.

Read full comparison →

J.B. Hunt Transport Services

4.1/5 rating

VS

Knight-Swift Transportation

3.5/5 rating

Score: 39Score: 35

J.B. Hunt and Knight-Swift are the two largest trucking companies in North America by revenue. J.B. Hunt pioneered intermodal and is known for its DCS division, while Knight-Swift is the largest truckload carrier with the widest range of opportunities.

Read full comparison →

Old Dominion Freight Line

4.5/5 rating

VS

FedEx Freight

4.1/5 rating

Score: 42Score: 41

Old Dominion and FedEx Freight are two of the top LTL carriers. Old Dominion consistently wins industry awards for service quality and driver pay. FedEx Freight offers the backing of one of the world's largest corporations with a pension plan.

Read full comparison →

Prime Inc.

3.6/5 rating

VS

KLLM Transport

3.7/5 rating

Score: 35Score: 34

Prime and KLLM are two of the largest refrigerated carriers, making this a key comparison for drivers interested in reefer freight. Prime is larger with multiple divisions, while KLLM is a dedicated reefer specialist.

Read full comparison →

Ryder System

4/5 rating

VS

Penske Logistics

4.1/5 rating

Score: 41Score: 41

Ryder and Penske are the two largest truck leasing and fleet management companies, both employing thousands of CDL drivers in dedicated contract carriage. These are among the best local and regional driving jobs available with predictable routes and home daily schedules.

Read full comparison →

Walmart Transportation

4.7/5 rating

VS

Amazon Freight

3.8/5 rating

Score: 41Score: 37

Walmart and Amazon represent the two largest retailers' private fleet operations. Walmart's fleet is long-established with industry-leading pay, while Amazon's freight operation is newer and scaling rapidly with tech company benefits.

Read full comparison →

Landstar System

4.3/5 rating

VS

Mercer Transportation

4.1/5 rating

Score: 37Score: 36

Landstar and Mercer are two of the top owner-operator carriers. Landstar is larger with diverse freight types, while Mercer specializes in flatbed. Neither employs company drivers -- both connect independent owner-operators with freight.

Read full comparison →

ABF Freight (ArcBest)

3.9/5 rating

VS

TForce Freight (formerly UPS Freight)

3.6/5 rating

Score: 39Score: 39

ABF and TForce are both Teamsters-represented LTL carriers offering union-scale wages and benefits. ABF has been union since the 1930s, while TForce transitioned from UPS Freight to TFI International ownership in 2021.

Read full comparison →

Estes Express Lines

4.2/5 rating

VS

Old Dominion Freight Line

4.5/5 rating

Score: 41Score: 42

Estes and Old Dominion are both premier LTL carriers with roots in Virginia. Estes is the largest privately held LTL carrier with an ESOP, while Old Dominion is publicly traded and widely regarded as the best-operated LTL carrier.

Read full comparison →

Schneider National

4/5 rating

VS

J.B. Hunt Transport Services

4.1/5 rating

Score: 38Score: 39

Schneider and J.B. Hunt are two of the most respected names in trucking. Schneider is known for CDL training and its tanker division, while J.B. Hunt leads in intermodal and dedicated contract services with higher pay ceilings.

Read full comparison →

Knight-Swift Transportation

3.5/5 rating

VS

Heartland Express

3.6/5 rating

Score: 35Score: 35

Knight-Swift is the largest TL carrier with coast-to-coast operations, while Heartland focuses on short-to-medium haul in the eastern U.S. with more frequent home time. Both accept newer drivers but the driving experience differs significantly.

Read full comparison →

Walmart Transportation

4.7/5 rating

VS

Old Dominion Freight Line

4.5/5 rating

Score: 41Score: 42

Walmart and Old Dominion represent two of the highest-paying driving jobs -- one in private fleet, one in LTL. Both require significant experience and are considered premium aspirational positions.

Read full comparison →

Saia Inc.

4/5 rating

VS

Old Dominion Freight Line

4.5/5 rating

Score: 40Score: 42

Saia is a rapidly expanding LTL carrier going from regional Southeast to national. Old Dominion is the acknowledged industry leader. Both offer strong LTL careers, but Old Dominion's compensation is hard to beat.

Read full comparison →

FedEx Freight

4.1/5 rating

VS

XPO

3.7/5 rating

Score: 41Score: 40

FedEx Freight and XPO are two of the three largest LTL carriers. FedEx benefits from massive corporate infrastructure and brand, while XPO operates as a standalone LTL carrier. Both offer competitive pay with home-daily options.

Read full comparison →

Schneider National

4/5 rating

VS

Knight-Swift Transportation

3.5/5 rating

Score: 38Score: 35

Schneider and Knight-Swift both offer CDL training for new drivers. Schneider is known for diverse divisions including tanker, while Knight-Swift is the industry's largest carrier with the most openings.

Read full comparison →

R+L Carriers

4/5 rating

VS

Estes Express Lines

4.2/5 rating

Score: 39Score: 41

R+L and Estes are both family-owned, non-union LTL carriers with national coverage. Estes is larger with more service centers, while R+L is known for competitive linehaul pay.

Read full comparison →

Dayton Freight Lines

4.3/5 rating

VS

Holland (TFI International)

3.6/5 rating

Score: 40Score: 37

Both are Midwest-centric regional LTL carriers. Dayton Freight is privately owned with consistently high driver satisfaction. Holland is now part of TFI International after Yellow's closure. Dayton Freight serves 24 states; Holland covers Central and Southeast.

Read full comparison →

Averitt Express

4.2/5 rating

VS

Southeastern Freight Lines

4.1/5 rating

Score: 40Score: 38

Both are privately held LTL carriers with deep Southeast roots. Averitt has expanded into truckload and international, while Southeastern remains focused on regional LTL excellence. Both consistently earn high marks for service and driver satisfaction.

Read full comparison →

Prime Inc.

3.6/5 rating

VS

Schneider National

4/5 rating

Score: 35Score: 38

Prime and Schneider are two of the most popular first carriers for new CDL drivers. Prime is privately held with reefer, tanker, and flatbed. Schneider is publicly traded with van, tanker, intermodal, and dedicated. Both have large training operations.

Read full comparison →

US Xpress (Knight-Swift)

3.4/5 rating

VS

Covenant Transport

3.5/5 rating

Score: 34Score: 34

Both Chattanooga-based truckload carriers that were direct competitors for years before US Xpress was acquired by Knight-Swift in 2023. Both offer OTR, dedicated, and team driving with a strong Southeast presence.

Read full comparison →

Central Transport

3.5/5 rating

VS

Dayton Freight Lines

4.3/5 rating

Score: 37Score: 40

Both Michigan/Ohio-based LTL carriers with strong Midwest presence. Central Transport has national coverage while Dayton Freight is regional across 24 states. Dayton Freight consistently earns higher driver satisfaction.

Read full comparison →

Forward Air

3.7/5 rating

VS

FedEx Freight

4.1/5 rating

Score: 35Score: 41

Forward Air specializes in airport-to-airport deferred air freight and expedited LTL. FedEx Freight is a traditional full-service LTL carrier. Different market segments with different driver experiences.

Read full comparison →

Ruan Transportation

4/5 rating

VS

Ryder System

4/5 rating

Score: 39Score: 41

Both are dedicated contract carriage specialists. Ruan is privately held with Midwest roots specializing in bulk/tanker. Ryder is a publicly traded global fleet management company. Both offer home-daily positions with predictable routes.

Read full comparison →

Roadrunner Transportation

3.3/5 rating

VS

XPO

3.7/5 rating

Score: 33Score: 40

Both are national LTL carriers, but XPO is significantly larger and more established. Roadrunner focuses on long-haul metro-to-metro LTL after financial restructuring. XPO is the stronger choice for most drivers.

Read full comparison →

Werner Enterprises

3.8/5 rating

VS

Prime Inc.

3.6/5 rating

Score: 35Score: 35

Werner and Prime are two of the largest carriers actively recruiting new CDL drivers. Werner focuses on dry van and dedicated. Prime offers reefer, tanker, and flatbed divisions. Both are common first carriers.

Read full comparison →

J.B. Hunt Transport Services

4.1/5 rating

VS

Werner Enterprises

3.8/5 rating

Score: 38Score: 34

J.B. Hunt excels in intermodal and dedicated with higher pay ceilings. Werner is a traditional truckload carrier with a strong dedicated fleet and CDL graduate programs. J.B. Hunt is more selective in hiring.

Read full comparison →

Knight-Swift Transportation

3.5/5 rating

VS

Prime Inc.

3.6/5 rating

Score: 35Score: 35

The largest publicly traded TL carrier vs one of the largest privately held. Both offer CDL training but differ in fleet composition and specialty divisions.

Read full comparison →

Saia Inc.

4/5 rating

VS

Estes Express Lines

4.2/5 rating

Score: 40Score: 41

Saia is publicly traded and rapidly expanding its terminal network. Estes is the largest privately held LTL carrier with an ESOP. Both offer competitive LTL careers with home-daily options.

Read full comparison →

ABF Freight (ArcBest)

3.9/5 rating

VS

Old Dominion Freight Line

4.5/5 rating

Score: 39Score: 42

ABF is a Teamsters union LTL carrier under ArcBest. Old Dominion is non-union with profit sharing. ABF offers union protections and pension; Old Dominion offers higher total compensation.

Read full comparison →

FedEx Freight

4.1/5 rating

VS

Old Dominion Freight Line

4.5/5 rating

Score: 41Score: 42

The top two LTL employers compared. FedEx Freight is backed by FedEx with pension and tuition reimbursement. Old Dominion is the industry leader with profit sharing and stock purchase.

Read full comparison →

Covenant Transport

3.5/5 rating

VS

Heartland Express

3.6/5 rating

Score: 34Score: 35

Covenant is known for team driving and expedited freight. Heartland focuses on short-to-medium haul with more frequent home time. Different strengths for different driver priorities.

Read full comparison →

Old Dominion Freight Line

4.5/5 rating

VS

XPO

3.7/5 rating

Score: 42Score: 40

Old Dominion is the gold standard in LTL. XPO is a major competitor with a large terminal network and pension plan. Both offer home-daily city positions and competitive LTL pay.

Read full comparison →

Marten Transport

3.7/5 rating

VS

KLLM Transport

3.7/5 rating

Score: 36Score: 34

Marten and KLLM are both major temperature-controlled carriers competing for reefer drivers. Marten is publicly traded with diverse divisions. KLLM is a dedicated reefer specialist. Both haul produce, frozen foods, and temperature-sensitive freight.

Read full comparison →

CRST International

3.4/5 rating

VS

Prime Inc.

3.6/5 rating

Score: 34Score: 35

CRST and Prime are two of the most accessible carriers for new drivers with no experience. CRST is known for team driving through CRST Expedited. Prime offers more division variety. Both provide paid CDL training.

Read full comparison →

Crete Carrier Corporation

4/5 rating

VS

Werner Enterprises

3.8/5 rating

Score: 36Score: 35

Both Nebraska-based carriers with strong reputations. Crete Carrier is privately held with three divisions (dry van, reefer via Shaffer, flatbed via Hunt). Werner is publicly traded focusing on dry van and dedicated.

Read full comparison →

UPS (Tractor-Trailer Division)

4.5/5 rating

VS

FedEx Freight

4.1/5 rating

Score: 43Score: 41

UPS feeder drivers and FedEx Freight drivers represent two of the best-paid driving positions in the industry. UPS is Teamsters union with top-tier wages and pension. FedEx Freight is non-union with FedEx corporate benefits. Both offer home-daily positions.

Read full comparison →

NFI Industries

3.9/5 rating

VS

Ryder System

4/5 rating

Score: 40Score: 41

NFI and Ryder are both major dedicated contract carriage providers offering local and regional routes. NFI is privately held with strong Northeast and port drayage operations. Ryder is publicly traded with nationwide coverage.

Read full comparison →

Groendyke Transport

4.4/5 rating

VS

Schneider National

4/5 rating

Score: 40Score: 39

Groendyke is the largest privately held bulk tanker carrier in the U.S. specializing in chemicals and petroleum. Schneider's tanker division is one of the largest food-grade and chemical tanker operations. Both offer premium tanker pay.

Read full comparison →

Anderson Trucking Service

4.1/5 rating

VS

Mercer Transportation

4.1/5 rating

Score: 39Score: 36

ATS and Mercer are both leading flatbed and specialized carriers. ATS offers both company driver and owner-operator positions. Mercer is exclusively owner-operator. Both haul oversized, heavy, and specialized freight.

Read full comparison →

PAM Transport

3.3/5 rating

VS

Knight-Swift Transportation

3.5/5 rating

Score: 31Score: 35

PAM Transport is a smaller carrier specializing in automotive freight alongside dry van. Knight-Swift is the largest TL carrier. PAM is easier to get into but generally offers lower starting pay.

Read full comparison →

Walmart Transportation

4.7/5 rating

VS

UPS (Tractor-Trailer Division)

4.5/5 rating

Score: 40Score: 42

The two highest-paying driving positions in America compared. Walmart is a private fleet with $87K-$110K+ pay. UPS feeder is a Teamsters union position with $80K-$120K+. Both are extremely competitive to get hired at.

Read full comparison →

Heartland Express

3.6/5 rating

VS

USA Truck (DB Schenker)

3.3/5 rating

Score: 38Score: 35

Heartland focuses on short-to-medium haul with newer equipment. USA Truck offers OTR and regional with DB Schenker backing. Heartland is the stronger choice for most drivers.

Read full comparison →

Schneider National

4/5 rating

VS

Heartland Express

3.6/5 rating

Score: 38Score: 35

Schneider is a diversified mega carrier with CDL training. Heartland is a truckload specialist focused on short-to-medium haul. Schneider offers more career paths; Heartland offers better home time.

Read full comparison →

J.B. Hunt Transport Services

4.1/5 rating

VS

Old Dominion Freight Line

4.5/5 rating

Score: 39Score: 42

Two of the best-paying carriers compared: J.B. Hunt's truckload/intermodal vs Old Dominion's LTL. Different types of driving with different lifestyles. Both are premium employers.

Read full comparison →

Prime Inc.

3.6/5 rating

VS

Covenant Transport

3.5/5 rating

Score: 36Score: 36

Both accept drivers with no experience and provide CDL training. Prime has more division variety (reefer, tanker, flatbed). Covenant excels in team driving and expedited freight.

Read full comparison →

Werner Enterprises

3.8/5 rating

VS

J.B. Hunt Transport Services

4.1/5 rating

Score: 34Score: 38

Werner is accessible to new CDL holders with solid dedicated freight. J.B. Hunt pays more and offers better home time but is more selective. A common career progression goes from Werner to J.B. Hunt.

Read full comparison →

Knight-Swift Transportation

3.5/5 rating

VS

Schneider National

4/5 rating

Score: 35Score: 38

The largest TL carrier vs one of the most diversified. Knight-Swift has more openings; Schneider has better equipment and more division variety.

Read full comparison →

Old Dominion Freight Line

4.5/5 rating

VS

Saia Inc.

4/5 rating

Score: 42Score: 40

The industry's best-run LTL carrier vs a rapidly growing national competitor. Old Dominion pays more; Saia has more openings due to expansion.

Read full comparison →

Estes Express Lines

4.2/5 rating

VS

FedEx Freight

4.1/5 rating

Score: 41Score: 42

Estes is the largest privately held LTL carrier with ESOP. FedEx Freight carries the FedEx brand with pension and tuition reimbursement. Both are top-tier LTL employers.

Read full comparison →

XPO

3.7/5 rating

VS

Saia Inc.

4/5 rating

Score: 40Score: 40

Two major non-union national LTL carriers. XPO is larger with a pension plan. Saia is growing faster with stock purchase options. Both offer competitive LTL careers.

Read full comparison →

Werner Enterprises

3.8/5 rating

VS

Heartland Express

3.6/5 rating

Score: 34Score: 35

Werner is a diversified mega carrier accepting new CDL graduates. Heartland focuses on short-haul with better home time but prefers experienced drivers.

Read full comparison →

J.B. Hunt Transport Services

4.1/5 rating

VS

Walmart Transportation

4.7/5 rating

Score: 39Score: 41

Two Arkansas-headquartered giants. J.B. Hunt is a for-hire carrier with diverse divisions. Walmart is a private fleet with the highest base pay in trucking. Both are premium employers.

Read full comparison →

Knight-Swift Transportation

3.5/5 rating

VS

Covenant Transport

3.5/5 rating

Score: 35Score: 34

The largest TL carrier vs a mid-size specialist in team driving and expedited. Knight-Swift has more openings; Covenant has a stronger niche in team driving.

Read full comparison →

Penske Logistics

4.1/5 rating

VS

Walmart Transportation

4.7/5 rating

Score: 41Score: 41

Two premium dedicated driving positions. Penske offers home daily with brand-new trucks. Walmart offers the highest pay in trucking with home weekly. Both require experience.

Read full comparison →

Amazon Freight

3.8/5 rating

VS

Ryder System

4/5 rating

Score: 37Score: 41

Two dedicated/local driving options. Amazon offers tech company perks and rapid growth. Ryder offers established fleet management operations with predictable routes.

Read full comparison →

Schneider National

4/5 rating

VS

Prime Inc.

3.6/5 rating

Score: 38Score: 35

The two most popular carriers for brand-new CDL drivers. Schneider offers company-paid training with APU trucks and diverse divisions. Prime offers more specialty options with a lease purchase path.

Read full comparison →

Marten Transport

3.7/5 rating

VS

Prime Inc.

3.6/5 rating

Score: 36Score: 35

Two major reefer carriers compared for temperature-controlled hauling. Marten is publicly traded with newer equipment and better home time. Prime is larger with CDL training and more division flexibility.

Read full comparison →

Crete Carrier Corporation

4/5 rating

VS

Prime Inc.

3.6/5 rating

Score: 36Score: 35

Both privately held carriers accepting new drivers. Crete runs Kenworths and Peterbilts across three divisions (dry van, reefer via Shaffer, flatbed via Hunt). Prime offers CDL training with reefer, tanker, and flatbed divisions.

Read full comparison →

Estes Express Lines

4.2/5 rating

VS

ABF Freight (ArcBest)

3.9/5 rating

Score: 41Score: 39

Estes is the largest privately held LTL carrier (non-union, ESOP). ABF is a Teamsters union LTL carrier under ArcBest. Different models -- non-union with ownership vs union with pension.

Read full comparison →

Amazon Freight

3.8/5 rating

VS

Penske Logistics

4.1/5 rating

Score: 37Score: 41

Two major dedicated/local employers. Amazon offers tech company perks and growth. Penske offers established operations with brand-new trucks and predictable routes.

Read full comparison →

Southeastern Freight Lines

4.1/5 rating

VS

Dayton Freight Lines

4.3/5 rating

Score: 38Score: 40

Two of the best regional LTL carriers in different territories. Southeastern covers the Southeast and Mid-Atlantic. Dayton Freight covers the Midwest, Central, and Southeast. Both are privately held with strong cultures.

Read full comparison →

Holland (TFI International)

3.6/5 rating

VS

TForce Freight (formerly UPS Freight)

3.6/5 rating

Score: 37Score: 39

Both are now under TFI International's umbrella. Holland is a regional LTL carrier in the Central/Southeast U.S. TForce Freight is a national LTL carrier (formerly UPS Freight). Different coverage areas under the same parent.

Read full comparison →

J.B. Hunt Transport Services

4.1/5 rating

VS

FedEx Freight

4.1/5 rating

Score: 39Score: 41

J.B. Hunt's truckload/intermodal vs FedEx Freight's LTL. Different types of driving, different lifestyles. J.B. Hunt intermodal can match FedEx Freight's home-daily schedule with competitive pay.

Read full comparison →

Schneider National

4/5 rating

VS

Werner Enterprises

3.8/5 rating

Score: 38Score: 34

Two of the most compared mega carriers. Schneider has more diverse divisions and company-paid CDL training. Werner offers strong dedicated accounts and consistent mentoring. Both are publicly traded nationwide carriers.

Read full comparison →

Knight-Swift Transportation

3.5/5 rating

VS

US Xpress (Knight-Swift)

3.4/5 rating

Score: 35Score: 34

Knight-Swift now owns US Xpress (acquired 2023), but both brands still operate. The main question is which brand offers the better driving experience within the same parent company.

Read full comparison →

Groendyke Transport

4.4/5 rating

VS

Ruan Transportation

4/5 rating

Score: 40Score: 39

Two top tanker/bulk carriers compared. Groendyke is the largest private bulk tanker carrier specializing in chemicals. Ruan handles food-grade, chemical, and general bulk in dedicated operations.

Read full comparison →

Old Dominion Freight Line

4.5/5 rating

VS

Estes Express Lines

4.2/5 rating

Score: 42Score: 41

Both Virginia-based LTL leaders. Old Dominion is publicly traded with industry-best profit sharing. Estes is privately held with ESOP. Old Dominion pays more; Estes is easier to get into.

Read full comparison →

FedEx Freight

4.1/5 rating

VS

Saia Inc.

4/5 rating

Score: 41Score: 40

FedEx Freight is the largest LTL carrier with corporate backing and pension. Saia is a fast-growing national LTL with stock purchase. Both offer competitive LTL pay and home-daily city positions.

Read full comparison →

Anderson Trucking Service

4.1/5 rating

VS

Landstar System

4.3/5 rating

Score: 39Score: 37

ATS and Landstar are both major flatbed carriers. ATS offers company driver positions alongside O/O. Landstar is exclusively owner-operator. ATS provides a career path; Landstar provides O/O independence.

Read full comparison →

UPS (Tractor-Trailer Division)

4.5/5 rating

VS

Walmart Transportation

4.7/5 rating

Score: 42Score: 40

The two highest-paying CDL positions in America. UPS feeder offers Teamsters union wages and daily home time. Walmart offers the highest guaranteed base pay with weekly home time. Both are aspirational positions.

Read full comparison →

CRST International

3.4/5 rating

VS

Knight-Swift Transportation

3.5/5 rating

Score: 34Score: 35

Two large carriers accepting brand-new drivers. CRST is known for team driving through CRST Expedited. Knight-Swift has the widest range of solo and team opportunities through Swift Academy.

Read full comparison →

PAM Transport

3.3/5 rating

VS

Prime Inc.

3.6/5 rating

Score: 31Score: 35

Both accept new CDL holders. PAM has a niche in automotive hauling. Prime offers reefer, tanker, flatbed, and CDL training. Prime is the more versatile option.

Read full comparison →

NFI Industries

3.9/5 rating

VS

Penske Logistics

4.1/5 rating

Score: 40Score: 41

Two major dedicated carriers offering home-daily local routes. NFI is strong in the Northeast with port drayage. Penske has nationwide coverage with brand-new trucks.

Read full comparison →

XPO

3.7/5 rating

VS

ABF Freight (ArcBest)

3.9/5 rating

Score: 40Score: 39

Non-union national LTL (XPO) vs Teamsters union LTL (ABF). XPO offers a pension without union dues. ABF offers full Teamsters protections with seniority-based advancement.

Read full comparison →

Heartland Express

3.6/5 rating

VS

Knight-Swift Transportation

3.5/5 rating

Score: 35Score: 35

Heartland's short-haul model vs Knight-Swift's massive nationwide operation. Heartland for home time; Knight-Swift for training and job variety.

Read full comparison →

Walmart Transportation

4.7/5 rating

VS

FedEx Freight

4.1/5 rating

Score: 41Score: 41

Private fleet (Walmart) vs LTL (FedEx Freight). Walmart pays more but requires more experience and offers weekly home time. FedEx offers daily home time with pension.

Read full comparison →

Schneider National

4/5 rating

VS

Groendyke Transport

4.4/5 rating

Score: 39Score: 40

Schneider's tanker division is one of the largest. Groendyke is the pure tanker specialist with ESOP. Schneider trains from scratch; Groendyke requires experience.

Read full comparison →

J.B. Hunt Transport Services

4.1/5 rating

VS

Ryder System

4/5 rating

Score: 39Score: 40

J.B. Hunt DCS (dedicated) vs Ryder dedicated. Both offer home-time-friendly dedicated accounts. J.B. Hunt pays more on average; Ryder offers more consistency and better-maintained equipment.

Read full comparison →

Werner Enterprises

3.8/5 rating

VS

Covenant Transport

3.5/5 rating

Score: 35Score: 34

Werner is a dry van/dedicated carrier. Covenant specializes in team driving and expedited. Both accept new CDL holders. Werner for solo dedicated; Covenant for team expedited.

Read full comparison →

Prime Inc.

3.6/5 rating

VS

Knight-Swift Transportation

3.5/5 rating

Score: 35Score: 35

Two of the biggest CDL training carriers. Prime has more specialty divisions. Knight-Swift has more geographic coverage and job openings.

Read full comparison →

FedEx Freight

4.1/5 rating

VS

ABF Freight (ArcBest)

3.9/5 rating

Score: 41Score: 39

Non-union LTL with FedEx corporate backing vs Teamsters union LTL. FedEx offers pension and tuition reimbursement. ABF offers union protections and Teamsters pension.

Read full comparison →

Crete Carrier Corporation

4/5 rating

VS

Schneider National

4/5 rating

Score: 36Score: 38

Crete is privately held running Kenworths and Peterbilts across three divisions. Schneider is publicly traded with company-paid CDL training and APU trucks. Both accept new drivers.

Read full comparison →

J.B. Hunt Transport Services

4.1/5 rating

VS

Penske Logistics

4.1/5 rating

Score: 39Score: 41

J.B. Hunt's diverse divisions vs Penske's pure dedicated operations. J.B. Hunt offers more career variety and higher pay potential. Penske offers the most predictable schedule with brand-new trucks.

Read full comparison →

Saia Inc.

4/5 rating

VS

FedEx Freight

4.1/5 rating

Score: 40Score: 41

Growing national LTL vs the largest LTL carrier. Saia is expanding rapidly with more openings. FedEx Freight offers corporate backing and pension.

Read full comparison →

Estes Express Lines

4.2/5 rating

VS

Saia Inc.

4/5 rating

Score: 41Score: 40

The largest privately held LTL carrier (Estes, ESOP) vs a rapidly growing public LTL (Saia, stock purchase). Both non-union, both national, both excellent.

Read full comparison →

Old Dominion Freight Line

4.5/5 rating

VS

UPS (Tractor-Trailer Division)

4.5/5 rating

Score: 42Score: 42

The best LTL carrier vs the best-paying feeder position. Old Dominion offers profit sharing and premium LTL. UPS feeder offers Teamsters wages and the highest total comp in driving.

Read full comparison →

J.B. Hunt Transport Services

4.1/5 rating

VS

Prime Inc.

3.6/5 rating

Score: 38Score: 36

J.B. Hunt is the premium carrier for experienced drivers. Prime is the gateway carrier for new drivers. Many drivers train at Prime and move to J.B. Hunt.

Read full comparison →

Old Dominion Freight Line

4.5/5 rating

VS

Walmart Transportation

4.7/5 rating

Score: 42Score: 41

Two of the highest-paying driving positions compared. Old Dominion offers daily home time with profit sharing. Walmart offers the highest base pay with weekly home time.

Read full comparison →

XPO

3.7/5 rating

VS

Estes Express Lines

4.2/5 rating

Score: 40Score: 41

Two large non-union national LTL carriers. XPO offers a pension plan. Estes offers ESOP. Both provide home-daily city positions and competitive pay.

Read full comparison →

Schneider National

4/5 rating

VS

Crete Carrier Corporation

4/5 rating

Score: 38Score: 36

Schneider offers company-paid CDL and tanker/intermodal. Crete offers KW/Peterbilt trucks across dry van/reefer/flatbed divisions. Both are excellent for new and experienced drivers.

Read full comparison →

Ryder System

4/5 rating

VS

Amazon Freight

3.8/5 rating

Score: 41Score: 37

Established fleet management giant vs the newest major fleet operator. Ryder offers 90+ years of stability and the best-maintained trucks. Amazon offers tech perks and rapid growth.

Read full comparison →

Heartland Express

3.6/5 rating

VS

Crete Carrier Corporation

4/5 rating

Score: 35Score: 36

Heartland's short-haul model vs Crete's multi-division operation. Heartland for home time. Crete for truck quality and division variety.

Read full comparison →

Averitt Express

4.2/5 rating

VS

Dayton Freight Lines

4.3/5 rating

Score: 40Score: 40

Two of the best regional LTL carriers serving different territories. Averitt covers the Southeast. Dayton Freight covers the Midwest. Both privately held with strong cultures.

Read full comparison →

Knight-Swift Transportation

3.5/5 rating

VS

Werner Enterprises

3.8/5 rating

Score: 35Score: 35

The largest TL carrier vs a respected mega carrier. Knight-Swift has more openings and CDL training. Werner has more consistent driver satisfaction and equipment.

Read full comparison →

UPS (Tractor-Trailer Division)

4.5/5 rating

VS

Old Dominion Freight Line

4.5/5 rating

Score: 42Score: 42

The highest-paying feeder job vs the highest-paying LTL job. UPS feeder pays more but is nearly impossible to get. Old Dominion is the realistic premium target.

Read full comparison →

J.B. Hunt Transport Services

4.1/5 rating

VS

Saia Inc.

4/5 rating

Score: 39Score: 40

Truckload/intermodal (J.B. Hunt) vs LTL (Saia). Different types of driving with different lifestyles. J.B. Hunt for variety and higher pay ceiling. Saia for consistent LTL with daily home time.

Read full comparison →

Walmart Transportation

4.7/5 rating

VS

Schneider National

4/5 rating

Score: 41Score: 39

The highest-paying private fleet vs one of the best training carriers. Walmart is the goal; Schneider is the starting point. Completely different experience requirements.

Read full comparison →

FedEx Freight

4.1/5 rating

VS

TForce Freight (formerly UPS Freight)

3.6/5 rating

Score: 41Score: 39

Non-union FedEx corporate vs Teamsters union TForce. FedEx offers corporate benefits and pension. TForce offers union wages and Teamsters protections.

Read full comparison →

Old Dominion Freight Line

4.5/5 rating

VS

ABF Freight (ArcBest)

3.9/5 rating

Score: 42Score: 39

The best non-union LTL carrier vs a respected Teamsters LTL carrier. Old Dominion pays more with profit sharing. ABF offers union protections and pension.

Read full comparison →

CRST International

3.4/5 rating

VS

Covenant Transport

3.5/5 rating

Score: 34Score: 34

Two carriers known for team driving. CRST Expedited pairs new drivers with experienced partners. Covenant offers team incentives with expedited freight. Both accept new CDL holders.

Read full comparison →

How We Compare Companies

Pay & Compensation

Base pay, bonuses, and total earnings potential across divisions.

Home Time

How frequently drivers get home based on division and route type.

Training Programs

CDL training availability, cost, and quality for new drivers.

Fleet & Equipment

Fleet size, average truck age, amenities, and maintenance standards.

Career Growth

Advancement opportunities, division transfers, and specialization paths.

Browse All Companies

View individual company profiles with detailed pay, benefits, and application information for all major carriers.

View All Companies